MTR Corporation Limited, founded in 1975 to provide efficient public transportation in Hong Kong, has grown into one of the world’s most successful transit operators, dominating Hong Kong’s transport and urban development through its “Rail + Property” business model. (Chan, L. S., 2023) This approach integrates rail operations with property development around stations, generating significant revenue while driving urban construction and housing production, solidifying MTR’s influence on city planning and the economy (Xu, 2015; Jauregui-Fung, 2022). With one of Asia's largest rail systems by size and revenue (MTR Corporation, 2024), MTR’s dominance impacts millions of lives daily, making corporate accountability critical to stakeholders, including customers, employees, investors, and regulators (Musil, 2019; Barber, 2020). However, such dominance is associated with immense corporate accountability, more so in a way that each stakeholder is interested in including customers, employees, investors, communities, and regulators.

This paper aims to determine how MTR implements stakeholders’ balance in its Corporate Social Responsibility programs. By analyzing the internal environment and external factors, this essay will evaluate MTR's broad and efficient CSR programs and recommend further enhancement.

PDF Version

CSR Activities Review

MTR offers fare concessions and concessionary ticket schemes for students, the elderly, and the deserving poor to reduce transport costs for some of the neediest in society (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024) , on environmental initiative, MTR has committed to reducing its carbon footprint through efficient energy use in train operations, encouraging green practices in property developments, and participating in other conservation-related projects (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024a). Additionally, MTR frequently organizes social services, such as community relations activities for youths, a public awareness crusade on safety measures, and corporate social responsibilities through partnerships with relevant non-governmental organizations (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024c). The company has robust workplace initiatives that are meant to motivate its staff, MTR focuses especially on employee care, training and development, worker safety, and issues of diversity and discrimination (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024a)

Carroll’s CSR Pyramid is a way to assess a company's CSR performance by dividing responsibilities into four levels: economic, legal, ethical, and philanthropic (Anderson, 2023). In this case, the above model can help evaluate the CSR activities developed by MTR concerning the above-mentioned societal perceptions on different levels. Analyzing MTR on these levels of responsibilities we can from economic responsibility perspective, MTR functions more as a business entity, producing nearly half its income from property and fares. It creates lasting shareholder value and reinvests to sustain the firm’s infrastructure (MTR Corporation, 2024). while at legal responsibility level, MTR corporation respects the laws of Hong Kong, hence addressing labour issues, environmental relations, and safety requirements of transport services (MTR Corporation Limited, 2022). Besides meeting legal requirements, MTR must conduct itself fairly in a business sense and be responsible for stakeholders (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024b). The preceding year saw some concern about ethics due to a rise in fares, which has been pictured as a monopolistic controller of fare rates. Analyzing the company from the Philanthropic, MTR undertakes many activities that are voluntary in nature and benefit the community, such as its community and environmental programs (MTR Corporation Limited, 2023).

Internal Factors Analysis

Resources and Capabilities

The CSR initiatives require substantial resources and capabilities, and MTR has ample resources to fund the implementations (Dragomir & Roxana, 2024).

As a profit-making entity with significant revenues from railway business and property developments, MTR has adequate financial muscle to fund long-term CSR projects (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024c). These resources help the company finance environmental projects, community undertakings, and fair concessionary measures.

MTR has also developed excellent transport technology and is widely used to reduce energy use in its operations (Chan, 2023). Examples of smart practices are using automated train systems and energy-efficient lighting systems in its operations, which enhance sustainable development. In addition, it can add value with innovative and sustainable building solutions in the real estate sector in its green practices.

On the aspect of human capital, MTR's large workforce, which includes professionals from transport, engineering, real estate, and customer care, is essential in delivering CSR (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024e). Extensive programs for training the company’s staff are provided to ensure that they understand CSR values, especially those concerning the safety of individuals, the environment, and customer relations.

Organisational Structure & Culture

The organizational structure of MTR is efficient to meet its complex needs in transport, property development, and overseas business (MTR Corporation, 2024).

In relation to decentralized structure for CSR, MTR maintains a decentralized structure where each business unit may independently conduct CSR activities suitable for its area of operation (transport, property, and international territories) (Barber, 2020). The decentralized structure allows for a dynamic and situation-sensitive strategy of CSR execution but also causes problems with integration across various organizational units.

From the perspective of dedicated CSR division, MTR has an organizational unit called Corporate Responsibility (Anderson, 2023), which monitors and coordinates the company's CSR initiatives. This ensures that CSR activities align with the company's strategic plan, that programs are checked, and that progress is documented.

MTR’s organizational culture is shaped by its public service delivery and considerate positioning as one of the city’s backbone infrastructure institutions (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024g). Organization culture and its people. The organization has stressed the comitment to service excellence. MTR plays a unique role in making sure that employees have a compassionate responsibility towards the public to ensure that optimum services are provided to the citizens. This detail is a customer-focused culture where CSR activities are directed towards the fact that the company should positively impact the community and environment.

About ethical behavior and transparency, to some extent, MTR has maintained high ethical standards when conducting its business operations and fully disclosing safety standards, environmental policies, and fares (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024b). However, criticisms about the perceived lack of transparency on fare adjustments are another area where people feel this culture needs to improve.

For a long time, the company's executive management has demonstrated an understanding of sustainability in the organization's future vision. MTR leadership team increases the awareness and advocacy for sustainability and social responsibility, and stakeholder engagement.

The leadership has supported and provided financial backing for green transportation technology and structures. Managers also interact with various community stakeholders to ensure that CSR meets society's expectations (MTR Corporation Limited, 2023a).

When it comes to stakeholder engagement, MTR’s leadership displays a good appreciation of the need for corporate profit to be made in consideration of the public (Chang & Phang, 2017). Therefore, ministerial and customer relations and interactions with local communities are successful strategies in managing CSR-related challenges in that they demonstrate a risk inertia theory in stakeholder management. Nevertheless, there are occasional complaints about leadership decisions, primarily to raise fares, noting that such measures adversely affect the low-income populace. These decisions provoke doubts regarding leadership’s CSR vision's applicability to women's employment.

Leadership

Stakeholder Analysis

Passengers

Customers of MTR services are an essential stakeholder group, and they are at the heart of all CSR activities in the organization (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024j). MTR strives to accommodate the transport needs of the public by envisaging friendly fares and proposing various fare subsidies for students, the elderly, and financially challenged folks. Nevertheless, fare increases experience, such as dissatisfaction with the passengers in specific areas such as Hong Kong (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024c).. Also, in the exposure draft of the Bill, passengers have high expectations of service quality, such as reliability and safety, which MTR counteracts through service improvement and station refurbishment. Another important factor is environmental sustainability; the method by which MTR has been cutting back its carbon footprint through low-energy trains and energy-efficient management is also in line with the passengers’ increasing consciousness.

Government

The Hong Kong government has a vested interest in MTR as it owns fifty percent plus one share in the company and also takes on the role of the company’s regulator. This impacts MTR CSR undertakings in two areas: regulatory and public policy (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024f). From the model, MTR is expected to adhere to safety, environment, and labor legal and ethical standards, which will be a responsible business responsibility (Aveline-Dubach & Blandeau, 2019). Furthermore, MTR aligns with government public policy measures, such as public transport and fighting carbon footprints. However, when fare adjustments occur, the public pressures the government to ensure MTR is responsive to its social obligations, especially to low-income people.

Employees

Employees in MTR are well-positioned to implement the company’s CSR plans and programs (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024j). Reasons for the strategy focus include MTR’s commitment to employee welfare through guaranteed attractive remuneration, packages, and comprehensive training. Well-being is always a concern, especially for the lower cadres, and MTR gives much cash to work on safety measures in the workplace (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024h). Furthermore, the company provides equal employment opportunities and diversity opportunities to support employee rights and equality, which is also part of the company’s overall CSR. It also directs the employees towards participating in CSR initiatives like social contribution and environmental management, strengthening corporate social responsibility with the firm's employee force.

Shareholders & Community Residents

The institutional investors, such as the Hong Kong government, who own shares in the enterprise are interested in good financial performance and, more so, the longevity of MTR (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024j). Shareholders generally approve CSR activities that help improve MTR’s reputation or reduce risk; however, CSR spending conflicts with profitability. For instance, shareholders may regard large expenditures on environmental issues or social activities that hurt immediate revenues. However, good CSR practices shield MTR against image threats detrimental to its stock value, which is good for long-term shareholders.

Many community residents, especially those residing within the MTR vicinity or any property development projects, influence MTR’s operations (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024j). Air and noise pollution and its impact on the physical environment, including fauna and flora, have become significant concerns of residents (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024j). MTR manages these concerns through green initiatives like noise reduction and some conservative projects. Nevertheless, the “Rail + Property “model has been associated with issues of regeneration and increasing property values around stations, claiming that the program mainly favours shareholders and affluent citizens (Musil, 2019). Nevertheless, MTR values communities’ involvement through educational activities, changes in public spaces, and cultural projects that benefit the company and increase social value.

External Factor Analysis (PESTEL framework)

Political (P)

MTR Corporation faces political pressure since the Hong Kong government owns it due to the majority shareholding, and the government has the power to regulate the company. Hence, government objectives like increasing investment in public transport, the provision of affordable fares, and the overall impact of the client company on the environment inform CSR strategies in MTR. MTR has constraints in matching its profitability agenda with the government expectations, especially whenever the adjustment of fares is politically contentious. However, the government's support provides possibilities for partnership in some infrastructural projects, policy-induced environmental objectives, and community-focused projects, which re-establishes the CSR fact of the MTR.

The CSR of MTR faces opportunities and threats from Hong Kong's economic environment. The high cost of living compels MTR to provide cheap means of transport, more so to the disadvantaged (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024c). Such aspects as market performance can dampen revenue generation, putting MTR under pressure to pursue the shareholders’ interests while financing CSR programs such as fare subsidies for the needy and enhancing the environmental responsiveness of its services. However, the "Rail + Property” model diversification of MTR is helpful because the company can reinvest the profits gained in its CSR activities during economic stability and maturity. Consequently, MTR’s CSR can encourage funds because it promotes itself as a sustainable, socially responsible organization appealing to equitable investors.

Societal trends in Hong Kong management make it difficult for MTR to effectively engage in its CSR activities (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024i). MTR is one of the most influential public services that takes responsibility for the multiple needs of passengers, employees, and the community. The growth of social consciousness regarding sustainable implementation also enhances the markets for environmentally friendly solutions such as energy-efficient trains or environmentally friendly designs of buildings (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024i). Challenges to corporate governance have also increased over the years, and the public looks forward to improving transparency in the corporate world and new scrutiny over MTR’s business, such as fares and property development. But it also has its opportunities side, the social pressure to fit in. By embracing sustainability and engaging local people, MTR can improve its image and adapt to consumers' increasing concerns about sustainability.

Economic (E)

Social (S)

Technological (T)

Current technological developments greatly facilitate the various CSR activities MTR can undertake. Implementing innovations in transport systems and bearing fixed rail-based transport systems, automation, and real-time information, without a doubt, saves energy (MTR Corporation Limited, 2023c). This element aligns with the company's sustainable environmental objectives. Nonetheless, technology faces issues regarding the digital divide, especially among elderly or marginalized individuals using the transport sector. With the increasing adoption of high-tech solutions by MTR, integrating all the demographic categories in society for technological solutions becomes part of the CSR strategy.

Environmental issues form the core of MTR’s CSR activity. Air pollution and the high population density have prioritized sustainable transport in Hong Kong (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024d). Another is innovation through energy-efficient MTR trains, waste minimization, and green property development. However, environmental laws are continually being enacted, and MTR requires enormous capital to meet the requirements of these Acts. This raises issues of financial cost, especially regarding balancing the green environment with the green pound.

The legal regulation to which MTR is subjected encompasses transportation services, the labor force, and environmental aspects (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024b). Legal regulation of company activity should not be violated, including health and safety rules, labor protection requirements, environmental legislation, etc. Legal risks occur each time regulations are adjusted, thus calling for MTR to invest hugely in infrastructure or operations. However, meeting and exceeding legal standards enables MTR to establish a positive CSR image and portray a positive image of a responsible corporate organization. There also lie legal imperatives that MTR can leverage to engage with relevant government priorities, such as a shift to green energy or social inclusion, to name a few, whereby MTR can proactively assume the mantle of corporate responsibility.

Environmental (E)

Legal (L)

Future CSR Performance Prediction

It is expected that MTR will continue to produce sound CSR performance in the future because of its prior experience, strong commitment to sustainability and stakeholders, environment, and public involvement. Considering the increasing environmental awareness, MTR will focus on green initiatives, electrification of its rolling stock, and environmentally friendly property developments (Xu, Y. 2015). This aligns with the global and regulatory call for carbon reduction, which will help play up MTR as a company with sustainable city development.

However, there will always be pressure to maintain profitability while the public demands cheaper and more transparent service delivery (MTR Corporation Limited, 2024c).. MTR may find itself receiving more attention to its fare policies and showing the population that continuing fare concessions will effectively eliminate income disparities in the transportation system. Also, the company’s property development activities may present continuing controversy over social justice issues. Still, it has ways to reduce such risk through inclusive community investments and affordable housing projects for the masses (Musil, C.,2019).

New technologies will create opportunities for new development, especially in the IT sphere, and access to them. Therefore, considering the implementation of stakeholder engagement concerning the dynamic socio-economic conditions, MTR can enhance its CSR image to be a model example for other companies. In conclusion, MTR is well placed to assume the leadership role of CSR in Hong Kong; its challenge will be to manage the fine line between optimizing business profitability and CSR delivery.

Improvement Suggestions

MTR may enhance its situation by responding more proactively to the issues related to the ‘‘Rail + Property’’ concept. If the company initiates more affordable housing projects or gives an excellent portion of the profits into social causes like community welfare and education, among others, then social equity would be much more compelling. This will assist in averting the negative perception of issues of gentrification as far as property investment is concerned.

On enhancing environmental activities, MTR could go further by boasting more challenging sustainability objectives, including shifting energy sourcing to renewable sources and providing stations from environmentally friendly materials. Another way to further enhance its position as an environmental pioneer would be to strengthen direct cooperation with local and international environmental nongovernmental organizations and governmental agencies to promote biological diversity protection and greening of cities.

Additionally, on transparency and inclusivity, MTR's future CSR reports should include suggestions based on standards such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), and the company should involve more stakeholders in its decision-making. Furthermore, it is necessary to enhance digital accessibility and provide appropriate services for elderly and disabled people to guarantee they receive all possible values from MTR's developed technologies.

Conclusion

CSR activities ongoing at MTR show that profit and non-profit organizations can work hand in hand, but more hurdles are present in efforts to address stakeholders’ concerns, especially on cost sensitivity, environmental impact, and community welfare. Through the proper use of resources, management, and technology, MTR is sure to contribute to the progressive changes in transportation and the urban setting of Hong Kong. Easy generation of profits in the future is contingent on honesty, improving the firm’s effects of environmentalism, and boosting social justice. By carefully strengthening these essentials, MTR is ready to steer and act as a responsible corporate citizen while fulfilling its sustained CSR goals and missions.

References

Anderson, K. (2023, January 13). Caroll’s CSR Pyramid: principles and examples. Greenly.earth. https://greenly.earth/en-gb/blog/company-guide/carolls-csr-pyramid-principles-and-examples

Aveline-Dubach, N., & Blandeau, G. (2019). The political economy of transit value capture: The changing business model of the MTRC in Hong Kong. Urban Studies, 56(16), 3415–3431. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042098018821519

Barber, L. B. (2020). Governing uneven mobilities: Walking and hierarchized circulation in HongKong.Journal of Transport Geography, 82, 102622. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2019.102622

Chan, L. S. (2023). Transition from fossil fuel propelled transport to electrified mass transit railway system - Experience from Hong Kong. Energy Policy, 173, 113372. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2022.113372

Chang, Z., & Phang, S.-Y. (2017). Urban rail transit PPPs: Lessons from East Asian cities. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 105, 106–122. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tra.2017.08.015

Dragomir, V.-D., & Roxana, E. (2024). Social Responsibility Practices Regarding Facilities Granted to Employees and Consumer Protection in Selected European Companies. Amfiteatru Economic Journal, 13(29), 86–103. http://hdl.handle.net/10419/168709

Jauregui-Fung, F. (2022). Land Value Capture and Transit Oriented Development as a Way of Funding Railway Systems: The Case of Hong Kong Rail + Property Model Report for the “Inclusive and sustainable smart cities in the framework of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development” Project IDOS NON-PAPER. https://www.idos-research.de/uploads/media/Jauregui-Fung_Hong_Kong_MTR_IDOS.pdf

MTR Corporation Limited. 2022). KEEP CITIES MOVING SUSTAINABLY. https://www.mtr.com.hk/sustainability/assets/pdf/en/2022/Sustainability_Report.pdf

MTR Corporation Limited. (2023a). Corporate Governance. Mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/sustainability/en/corporate_governance.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2023b). KEEP CITIES MOVING SUSTAINABLY CONTENTS. https://www.mtr.com.hk/sustainability/assets/pdf/en/2023/Sustainability_Report.pdf

MTR Corporation Limited. (2023c). MTR Utilises New Technologies to Elevate Customer Experience Foster Co-Creation and Youth Innovation via The Metaverse. https://www.mtr.com.hk/archive/corporate/en/press_release/PR-23-072-E.pdf

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024a). Advancement & Opportunities. Www.mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/sustainability/en/advancement-opportunities.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024b). Code of Conduct. Mtr.com.hk; MTR Corporation limited. https://www.mtr.com.hk/archive/corporate/en/publications/images/codeofconduct.pdf

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024c).Financial Sustainability. Www.mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/sustainability/en/financial-sustainability.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024d). Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction. Www.mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/sustainability/en/greenhouse-gas-emissions-reduction.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024e). HUMAN RESOURCES. Mtr.com.hk; MTR Corporation limited. https://www.mtr.com.hk/archive/corporate/en/investor/annual2023/E20.pdf

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024f). MTR > FAQ. Www.mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/en/corporate/investor/investor_faq.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024g). MTR > Special Schemes. Www.mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/en/customer/tickets/more_special_scheme.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024h). MTR > Why joining MTR. Www.mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/en/corporate/careers/why_joining_mtr.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024i). Social Inclusion. Www.mtr.com.hk. https://www.mtr.com.hk/sustainability/en/social-inclusion.html

MTR Corporation Limited. (2024j). STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT STAKEHOLDER GROUP HONG KONG BUSINESSES 2021 ENGAGEMENT ACTIONS AND ACHIEVEMENTS. https://www.mtr.com.hk/archive/corporate/en/investor/annual2021/E05.pdf

Musil, C. (2019). 10 hong kong’s “rail-plus-property” Development. Degruyter.com; Future Challenges of Cities in Asia. https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/9789048544912-010/pdf?licenseType=restricted

Xu, Y. (2015). Under What Circumstances Will Land Value Capture Work to Finance Public Transit? Based on Case Studies of Hong Kong, Tokyo and New York City. https://doi.org/10.7916/d8df6qc4